Compare
PMS vs Mutual Fund vs AIF vs SIF — which is right for you?
Updated: October 2026 · Baasava Hathiwala
If you want a professional to manage your money in India, you have four main routes: a mutual fund, a Specialised Investment Fund (SIF), a Portfolio Management Service (PMS), or an Alternative Investment Fund (AIF). They differ mainly in how much you need to start, how much freedom the manager has, how you hold the investment, and who they are designed for. Here is the whole picture on one page.
The comparison at a glance
| Feature | Mutual Fund | SIF | PMS | AIF |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum investment | No minimum (SIP from ₹500) | ₹10 lakh | ₹50 lakh | ₹1 crore |
| How you hold it | Units (pooled) | Units (pooled) | Shares in your own demat | Units (pooled) |
| Regulated as | Mutual fund | Mutual fund framework | PMS | AIF |
| Strategy flexibility | Lowest | High (long-short, derivatives) | High (bespoke) | Highest (unlisted, leverage) |
| Liquidity | High (daily) | Moderate | Moderate | Low (lock-ins) |
| Taxation of churn | Only when you redeem | Fund-level | Each sale is your taxable event | Category-dependent |
| Best suited to | Everyone | HNI / sophisticated | HNI (₹50L+) | UHNI / institutional |
Mutual funds — the foundation
No minimum, daily liquidity, strong regulation, and tax that is triggered only when you sell. For the vast majority of investors, mutual funds via SIP are the core of a sensible portfolio. Start with our live mutual fund data and the SIP calculator.
SIF — the new middle ground
SEBI's newest category (2025), the Specialised Investment Fund needs ₹10 lakh and lets managers use more advanced strategies — long-short, derivatives, dynamic allocation — than a regular mutual fund. It bridges the gap between mutual funds and PMS.
PMS — direct ownership for larger portfolios
A Portfolio Management Service holds shares directly in your own demat account, with a bespoke, concentrated strategy — but needs ₹50 lakh, charges higher fees, and creates a taxable event every time the manager sells. We maintain detailed, source-backed research on dozens of PMS strategies.
AIF — the specialist's tool
An Alternative Investment Fund needs ₹1 crore and offers the widest freedom — private equity, venture capital, real estate, hedge-fund-style strategies — for ultra-HNI and institutional investors willing to accept illiquidity.
How to choose
- By how much you can invest: under ₹10 lakh → mutual funds; ₹10–50 lakh → mutual funds or a SIF; ₹50 lakh+ → add PMS to the mix; ₹1 crore+ and sophisticated → AIFs become an option.
- By how hands-off you want to be: all four are professionally managed, but mutual funds and SIFs are the simplest to hold.
- By whether you want to own the shares yourself: only PMS gives you direct demat ownership.
- By tax sensitivity: pooled vehicles (mutual fund, SIF, AIF) don't create a tax event every time the manager trades; a PMS does.
A simple way to think about it
Build your core with mutual funds. Add a SIF, PMS or AIF only when you have a larger corpus and a specific reason — more flexibility, direct ownership, or access to alternative assets. More money doesn't automatically mean a more exotic product is better; the right choice is the one that fits your goals, horizon and risk appetite.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a mutual fund, SIF, PMS and AIF?
They are four ways to invest through a professional in India, in rising order of ticket size and flexibility. Mutual funds have no minimum and the least flexibility; SIFs need ₹10 lakh and can use advanced strategies; PMS needs ₹50 lakh and holds shares in your own demat account; AIFs need ₹1 crore and can invest in unlisted and alternative assets.
Which has the lowest minimum investment?
Mutual funds — you can start a SIP from as little as ₹500. Among the more specialised options, a SIF has the lowest minimum at ₹10 lakh, followed by PMS at ₹50 lakh and AIF at ₹1 crore.
Is PMS better than mutual funds?
Not inherently. PMS offers direct ownership and a more concentrated, bespoke portfolio, but with a ₹50 lakh minimum, higher fees and more tax events from in-portfolio churn. For most investors, mutual funds are the sensible core; PMS makes sense only for larger portfolios with a specific reason for direct ownership.
Which option should a first-time investor choose?
Almost always a mutual fund, usually through a SIP. It has no minimum, strong regulation, daily liquidity and tax that is only triggered when you sell. The specialised options (SIF, PMS, AIF) are for investors with larger amounts and more specific needs.
Explore & decide
Play with the trade-offs in our Make Money or Build Wealth tool, dive into PMS strategy research, read the SIF and AIF guides, or talk to Baasava Hathiwala.
For education and information only — not investment advice or a recommendation. All these products are subject to market and other risks; read the relevant documents and consider your own circumstances before investing. See our disclaimer.